Nancy Ann Gengnagel Obituary

We are sad to announce that on July 10, 2025, Nancy Ann Gengnagel (Zionsville, Indiana) passed away. Family and friends are welcome to leave their condolences on this memorial page and share them with the family.

She was predeceased by: her parents, Willard Underhill and Marjorie Underhill (Graf); her friend Bill Crone; her husband Edward Gengnagel; and her brother Tom Underhill.

She is survived by: her daughters, Sally Gillihan (John) and Susan Raibikis (Vic); her grandchildren, Matthew Gillihan (Amanda), David Gillihan (Lizzy), Kesley Raibikis and Jack Raibikis (Jen); her great grandchildren, Sophia, Scottie and Sam; and her brother Sam Underhill (Kathy).

In lieu of flowers and to honor Nancy's love of reading to children, memorial contributions can be made to: Carmel, Indiana Public Library (https://carmelclaylibrary.org).

Funeral arrangement under the care of
Flanner & Buchanan Cremation and Burial

Report

Edit Report Authorize the original

Send Flowers

Share your support

Light a candle

Illuminate their memory

Give a memorial tree

Plant a tree

Sympathy messages

Would you like to offer Nancy Ann Gengnagel’s loved ones a condolence message? Write your message of sympathy today.

Add a photo or a video

There is no photo or video of Nancy Ann Gengnagel.
Be the first to share a memory to pay tribute.

Add a photo

Family member

Solidarity program

Echovita offers a unique service that allows funds generated by the obituary notice to be shared with families that request it.

Make a request

Authorize the original obituary

Lets us publish the full obituary text along with the original picture.
Helps people recognize Nancy Ann Gengnagel and express their condolences more easily.
No advertising will be displayed on this page.

Authorize the original